Seej AfricaSeej Africa
  • Home
  • Our Story
    • About Us
    • History
    • Mission & Values
  • Wildlife Cases in The Courts
    • Active Case Index
    • Terms and Abbreviations
    • Concluded Case Index
    • 2023
    • 2022
    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • Pre 2013
  • Major Wildlife Seizures
  • West African Crime Group
  • News
    • Kenya
    • Africa
    • International
  • Commentary
  • Contact us
Reading: 418/17 Shanzu – Prosecution Concludes in 2014 Ivory Seizure Case from Singapore
Share
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
Seej AfricaSeej Africa
  • Home
  • Our Story
  • Wildlife Cases in The Courts
  • Major Wildlife Seizures
  • West African Crime Group
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Contact us
  • Home
  • Our Story
    • About Us
    • History
    • Mission & Values
  • Wildlife Cases in The Courts
    • Active Case Index
    • Terms and Abbreviations
    • Concluded Case Index
    • 2023
    • 2022
    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • Pre 2013
  • Major Wildlife Seizures
  • West African Crime Group
  • News
    • Kenya
    • Africa
    • International
  • Commentary
  • Contact us
Have an existing account? Sign In
© Seej Africa. All Rights Reserved.
Seej Africa > Blog > 2017 > 418/17 Shanzu – Prosecution Concludes in 2014 Ivory Seizure Case from Singapore
2017Active Case IndexMajor Wildlife SeizuresWildlife Crime Courtroom Watch

418/17 Shanzu – Prosecution Concludes in 2014 Ivory Seizure Case from Singapore

SEEJ-AFRICA
Last updated: August 23, 2023 2:53 pm
SEEJ-AFRICA Published April 8, 2022
Share
Republic vs. Falah Manzu Yusuf @ Mohamed Faki and 5 others - 1004 kg of ivory seized in crates amidst 200 bags of Uganda coffee

April 8th, 2022: The prosecutions case was concluded today when the last witness testified in an eight year old ivory seizure investigation.  

On March 28th, 2014, Singapore authorities verified a sea container cargo that was found to contain 106 pieces of ivory weighing 1004 kg amongst 200 bags of coffee beans. The container originated from Kampala, Uganda, and transited through Mombasa in late January 2014. 

It was initially reported that this investigation commenced in late 2015, through a joint task force supported by the NGO ‘Freeland’, in cooperation with  the Lusaka Agreement Task Force (LATF) based in Nairobi.  Investigators were focused on two other seizures that had initiated/transited Pointe Noire, Congo, in 2014 and early 2015.  Those investigations yielded intelligence connecting them to this seizure presently before the court.

However, through the testimony of Superintendent James Githinji of the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) on Thursday, it became clear that this shipment had been the object of scrutiny by DCI and Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) before the container had been opened in Singapore in March 2014.  This information would suggest that at the time, persons within DCI or the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) had declined to proceed with the investigation/prosecution until being re-vitalized in 2017.

The prosecution and defence now await the decision of Chief Magistrate Florence Macharia as to whether enough evidence has been submitted to prove  a prima facie case.
 
There are a number of critical considerations for the court to consider as follows:
 
1. There is no scientific report before the court that the ivory seized in Singapore is actually ivory.  This is an essential criteria for ivory cases in Kenya. It had been discovered too late that a scientific DNA analysis of the ivory had been conducted in August 2014.
 
2. No report or affidavit relating to Singapore’s authorities involvement with this ivory seizure was forwarded to Kenya investigators and/or made its way to the prosecution file. Also, while photograph’s of the container and contents were provided, there was no detail as to date or time or by who? 
 
3. All of the accused but one were involved in the movement of the container from Uganda to Mombasa Port. As is usual with such prosecutions, no direct evidence was before the court that the five accused had specific knowledge of ivory in the container. 
 
4. This is compounded by evidence indicating that a seal(s) had been removed and the very real possibility that ivory was added to the container when it reached Mombasa. (See DNA map)
 
5. While Mpesa money transactions were presented in court as evidence of financial transactions between some of the accused, the payments have not been tied specifically to the container or its contents.
The DNA analysis, with the blue circles indicating within 200 - 300 km where the elephants had been killed. The ivory came primarily from Tanzania followed by Kenya. (Courtesy Centre for Environmental Forensic Science.)

CM Macharia has given both prosecution and defence until April 22nd, 2022 to provide their submissions as to whether the accused have a case to answer.

In February of this year,  Dr. Samuel Wasser et al published a report, “Elephant genotypes reveal the size and connectivity of transnational ivory traffickers”, in which this particular seizure was shown to be connected to many others throughout East and West Africa.  Unfortunately, none of that information made it into evidence for this trial.

You Might Also Like

Failed or ‘Failed’? Postmortem of an Ivory Prosecution (pdf)

Case Review – Two men sentenced to 9 and 7 years imprisonment for trafficking 209 kg ivory. Would you convict?

E071/24 Kahawa – R. vs. Richard Kipleting Kuto, Cpl. Ben Kipkosgei Kiplangat, Charles Nzuki Mutua, Philip Lubanga Adembe – 29 kg ivory

Nationals from Burundi, Rwanda and Congo in latest ivory capture – 13 kg

E052/24 Kahawa – R. vs. Erick Theuri Wairimu + 2 others 28 kg Ivory

TAGGED:DNA AnalysedWest African Crime Group Linkage
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Copy Link Print
Previous Article 2021 Numbers (Unofficial) Indicate that Poaching/Trafficking Still Active in Kenya
Next Article Mombasa Court Orders KWS to Provide Permits for Illegal Rosewood Seizure
Popular News
Nkubu Township, Meru: Three arrested with 2 pieces ivory weighing 60 kg
April 2009 – 703 kg of Ivory Seized From Vehicle Travelling From Tanzania
July 2009: Jomo Kenyatta IA – Kenya seizes coffin-stashed ivory

Popular Tags

2015 2017 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Acquittal Bushmeat Compromised Compromise Indicators Conviction Corruption Deportation DNA Analysed Escapee JKIA Kahawa Kenya Wildlife Task Force Linked Seizure No Prosecution Pangolin Police arrested Quashed Conviction Rhino Rosewood Sandalwood Sentencing The Sheikh's Voi Warrant West African Crime Group Linkage Withdrawn

OUR STORY

  • About
    About
  • History
    History
  • Mission & Values
    Mission & Values
  • Funding
    Funding

NEWS

  • Kenya
    Kenya
  • Africa
    Africa
  • International
    International

WILDLIFE COURT CASES

  • Active Case Index
    Active Case Index
  • Concluded Case Index
    Concluded Case Index
  • Terms & Abbreviations
    Terms & Abbreviations

CONTACT INFO

©2023 Seej Africa. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?